Free Shipping in India For Orders Valued More Than Rs. 1000/- Sign Up Now! Get 5% OFF

Pierre-Simon Laplace, a distinguished Fre-nch mathematician of the 19th century, made very valuable contributions to the subject of Newtonian dynamics and gravitation. His work on the solar system involved solving the problem of motions of all the known members of the solar system, including planets, satellites and smaller bodies. And the success of the effort covering five thick volumes lay in the fact that the theoretical des-cription matched observations. As a matter of courtesy, Laplace called on Emperor Napoleon to present him with this work. As Napoleon turned over the pages, he realised that the mathematics would go well above his head. Still, after a brief perusal he asked the scientist what he considered a pertinent question: "M. Laplace, I do not see any mention of God in your description of the solar system." To which, Laplace replied: "I had no need of that hypothesis (Je n'avais pas besoin de cette hypothèse-lè)."

Indeed, science attempts to explain the complex phenomena in nature, without recourse to divine interventions. Seen in that light, Laplace's reply shows his rationalism. But how many scientists can claim to follow that route? Indeed it appears that their mindset is compartmentalised with one part, of rational scientific enquiry, activated during their laboratory hours with the other, superstitious part, taking over the moment they step out of their labs. Otherwise, it is hard to understand events like the annual "worship" of scientific instruments, on Vishwakarma Puja day. A housing unit in the quarters of a national laboratory remained unoccupied as it was believed to be haunted.

There are a minority of scientists who can react rationally in the presence of "miracle makers". There is the story of a scientist who was presented with a watch by a holy man who apparently produced it out of nothing. Without touching the watch lying on the floor in front, the scientist said: "Sir, you have performed a miracle in generating this watch out of vacuum. I will become your disciple, if you can move it further towards me no more than six inches." Needless to say, the holy man did not get a disciple that day.

 

If this is the state of rationalism in the scientific community, one can imagine the state of the common man. There are numerous superstitions that have taken charge of the common mindset. Even if scientists try to convince him that applying statistical techniques to large samples demonstrates that astrological predictions are no better than chance predictions, he wants to believe in it. This is because in today's high-pressure life he is forced to take decisions that matter.

In such cases a successful astrologer fills the gap by offering solace based on planets. The analysis will be unscientific, but the client is satisfied.

An interesting sidelight on superstitions has been thrown by Jiri Grygar, a scientist from the Czech Republic. He finds that during the Soviet-dominated era no superstitious ideas were publicly aired as these were feared to be against the beliefs subscribed to by the state.

There are, however, new superstitions that have their origin in space technology. Towards the end of the last century I had gone on a visit to the radio telescope at Arecibo in Puerto Rico. Now Puerto Rico forms one of the vertices of a rather notorious triangle whose other vertices are at Bermuda and Florida. Known as the Bermuda Triangle, it has generated considerable excitement because of a claim that it formed a region within which mysterious forces are present. A book on Bermuda Triangle by Charles Berlitz describing disturbing events makes fascinating reading. If those accounts were true then the Bermuda Triangle indeed encompassed a sinister region. There were accounts of pilots losing their way and their lives, watches stopping for an appreciable time.

There followed, a few years later, scientific attempts to test the veracity of the Triangle events. Lawrence David Kusche, a librarian, did seminal work in debugging the Triangle stories. His investigations have shown that the stories did not tell the truth.

But we Indians somehow feel that life needs to be peppered with superstitions. I call these space age superstitions, for the advent of space technology made it easier to imagine these extrapolations.

The writer, an astrophysicist, is professor emeritus at Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Pune University Campus

Link: http://www.deccanchronicle.com/columnists/jayant-v-narlikar/superstitions-space-age#.UGkj_9dUX_s.facebook

Reproduced by permission from Mr. Rahul Gupta from his post in the Facebook group ‘Astrologers from ICAS’

 

Superstitions of the space age

WA button WA button